
Originally Posted by
Noblejanobii
Actually Liebeck v. McDonalds was a really important case. I had to study it in one of my criminal law classes in high school and at first all of us were like "oh yeah she's totally stupid" but then when you go look at the facts, it's actually not the cash grab everyone thinks it is. Firstly, Stella Liebeck wasn't the one driving the car, her grandson was. Secondly, they were in a parked car and she was holding the coffee in her lap when it spilled. Thirdly, Stella openly admitted the spill was her mistake, so she wasn't suing over her spilling the coffee. However, that didn't change the outcome. Stella had to go to the hospital for third degree burns on her legs and genitals, which means the coffee had to be at least 120 degrees, depending on how much exposure she had to the coffee, and most reports say the coffee was actually somewhere around 170 to 180 degrees! She ended up going in shock and had to undergo skin grafting operations, to which Stella's surgeon said it was one of the worst cases of third degree burns he had ever seen. Stella suffered permanent disfigurement and nearly died as a result of the accident. See, McDonalds used to preheat their coffees in the morning to almost 200 degrees every morning because they got a lot of complaints about their coffee not being hot enough. McDonalds even admitted that their coffee was a hazard at that temperature! In fact, in the decade prior to that case, over 700 people had notified McDonalds that they had suffered awful burns from spilling their coffee on themselves. And here's the real kicker, Stella didn't even want to go to court. She just wanted McDonalds to help pay her $20,000 in out of pocket medical expenses that her insurance wouldn't cover. But after 8 months of negotiating, do you know what McDonalds offered? $800. $800. Stella tried to settle with McDonalds and even agreed to mediation but the multi-billion dollar corporation wouldn't budge, giving her no choice but to go to court. So they did, and Stella actually won the case! The jury found McDonalds guilty and punished them, hoping to teach the company a lesson. And it worked, because McDonalds lowered the temperature of their coffee and they've stopped burning people. Stella even got a settlement of $6000 from McDonalds, a huge help to her medical bills. This was actually a landmark case in which a working class citizens beat out a bunch of corporate lawyers! So why have you never heard of it? Because those corporate lawyers are snakes that are really good at being snakes. They ran a huge disinformation campaign to spread all the lies that Stella was a greedy old lady that had only sued McDonalds because she wanted to become a millionaire. And the media ate it, starting this whole idea of "an epidemic of frivolous lawsuits". Even many of the protests that you see about stopping frivolous lawsuits are paid for by corporations. It's all a scam to keep people from suing big bucks corporations because they don't to be seen as people who are a part of a frivolous lawsuit. And it's worked. Personal injury lawsuits are at an all time low in recent years because of stuff like this because people don't think to check the facts behind what's being told to them. Heck, they even did an Adam Ruins Everything episode on this that I just went and rewatched to make sure most of my facts were correct!
So, Neo, you're wrong, Stella didn't sue McDonalds because she was driving recklessly and spilled hot coffee on herself. She and her grandson were in a parked car that her son had driven to McDonalds to get the coffee, Stella openly admitted that the spilling of the coffee was her fault, she didn't even want to go to court, but because McDonalds refused to help pay the medicals bills for her near death experience, she was forced to, and as a result, McDonalds and a bunch of other companies with high risk products dragged her name through the mud to ensure it didn't happen again.
Bookmarks