I never realized all the different ways. Never thought about it, but my friend agrees with the jam-in-the-middle method and it works well when I do it, so that's now my go-to.

I also just accidentally toasted the bread while making one and it...was not very good.

So, how do you make yours?

EDIT: Someone edit my poll for me. xO My dumb phone corrected "jelly" to "kept."