Revisiting this thread, I realize there was a lot more to unpack about peoples expectations and values irl as well as just a game decision! So, I can understand people having strong views. Some similar IRL things are like;

- Do murderers deserve the death penalty?
- By having the power to condemn someone for eternity vs sacrificing innocents, are we also grappling with peoples religious ideals about what is truly good?
- Where do we draw the line between purging sins and saving the town/world? Are they always the same thing?
- Is life in the moment more important than the afterlife?

So, I see it can get digging into political, personal and religious world views! I didn't really intend that; I just wanted to try out an action I've never seen used, in a game where I felt it was ok to experiment, and thought I'd better go over it first with my teammates.

Anyway!
I've got my answers, and extra!
☆ Dont kill any stalkers unless I want Shruikan to quit the game
☆ Don't waste my actions on random stuff or Truly will be more frustrated
☆ Noble is ... something! Not a fan of any death and willing to compromise?

Thankyou all for engaging in this thread! It's been a ride!
I'm happy to lock it up and close the poll, lol.