Lol I've been playing mostly M for Mature games now and forgot what T and E games I like. If you permit M rated games at all then I recommend The Last of Us. Trust me, it's way better than a Call of Duty FPS game. The setting, plot, and characters, as much as the gameplay, are intriguing. And I pretty much hate on shooter games besides Resident Evil.

I actually just started playing Soul Calibur V and I enjoy it. Good recommendation, Corey.

And I echo the Tales of series. I haven't played Xillia yet but I'm sure it's good. Graces was good.

I had a lot of fun doing the Colosseum on KH 1.5, especially fighting the Ice Titan. Still haven't done everything I want on the game to finally beat the Mystery boss and Sephiroth.