The (Not Sponsored by PXR) PXR Mafia - Rebooted (EELS) [Full]

[Bulbasaur]

Do I want to get killed first round again?
...
Eh, why not. I'll join.

[Dragon Master Mike]

I want in!

[Sonic20]

Count me in.

[Metal Gear Snivy]

It should probably be in the 5-10 day range, and we probably shouldn't start unless there's at least 8 people, which gives us 2 Non-eels and 6 real Eels for a fairly even game. Seem fair?

Yeah that seems good. Or we could give 4 Non-Eels and 4 Eels to make it fair. Given that the Eel roles are more diverse, if there happens to be 4 roles that can do stuff with 2 regular Eels and there would only be one Mastermind and Grunt, meaning that given the Mastermind role can evade, it doesn't really seem too fair. Though, I get why there would be less Non-Eels, so maybe around 3 Non-Eels and 5 Eels, just to make it a little more fair.

Do I want to get killed first round again?
...
Eh, why not. I'll join.

<3

[The Nonexistent Tazz]

Trust me. 1:3 Non-Eels to Eels is the golden ratio. There should always be exactly 1 Hunter and Medic (Granted, having the Medic double as the Prinny for the night round is a new one), but Masterminds are only if there are 3 confirmed Mafia members. Really, the Ratio is best.

TRUST ME.

TRUST ME SNIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVY!

[Shiny Totodile]

YourAvatar (8).jpgThe Hunter.

YourAvatar (9).jpgThe Goon.

[Metal Gear Snivy]

Trust me. 1:3 Non-Eels to Eels is the golden ratio. There should always be exactly 1 Hunter and Medic (Granted, having the Medic double as the Prinny for the night round is a new one), but Masterminds are only if there are 3 confirmed Mafia members. Really, the Ratio is best.

TRUST ME.

TRUST ME SNIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVY!

Ah, okay. I understand it now. So the layout would be 1 Hunter, 1 Savior, 1 Village Leader, 3 Villagers, 1 Mastermind, and 1 Goon, correct?

Also, thanks again Totodile~

[The Nonexistent Tazz]

I wouldn't include the Mastermind at all if there's only two non-eels to find, as it weakens the Hunter's role severely. Imagine if there actually WAS a Godfather/Mastermind last game, and it was me-yeah, we'd have won much easier if I was 'known' as a completely normal villager instead of ratted out as a Mafia by you. Having exactly one meaningful guy to search also makes it a lot harder for the villagers to do anything meaningful with said hunter. But other than that, yes, that's basically how I'd do it.

Also: I can assume that, if we have roles like the Hunter and the Savior, that our abilities are activated during the day but take place during the night round (the questioning and the protection)?

[Metal Gear Snivy]

I wouldn't include the Mastermind at all if there's only two non-eels to find, as it weakens the Hunter's role severely. Imagine if there actually WAS a Godfather/Mastermind last game, and it was me-yeah, we'd have won much easier if I was 'known' as a completely normal villager instead of ratted out as a Mafia by you. Having exactly one meaningful guy to search also makes it a lot harder for the villagers to do anything meaningful with said hunter. But other than that, yes, that's basically how I'd do it.

Also: I can assume that, if we have roles like the Hunter and the Savior, that our abilities are activated during the day but take place during the night round (the questioning and the protection)?

Ah, I see about that. But, if there happens to be more than 8, should there be a Mastermind, since we could slap an extra one onto the Non-Eels side?

And as for the Hunter and Savior, the Hunter's effect takes place during the Day (I'll make sure to message whoever has the role before Night starts) and the Savior PM's me during the day who to protect during the Night. So, the Hunter's ability takes place during the Day and the Savior's ability takes place during the Night once they have PM'd me.

[The Nonexistent Tazz]

Ah, I see about that. But, if there happens to be more than 8, should there be a Mastermind, since we could slap an extra one onto the Non-Eels side?

And as for the Hunter and Savior, the Hunter's effect takes place during the Day (I'll make sure to message whoever has the role before Night starts) and the Savior PM's me during the day who to protect during the Night. So, the Hunter's ability takes place during the Day and the Savior's ability takes place during the Night once they have PM'd me.

I'd add a Mastermind as an extra Mafia on 11 or 12 people joining. 9 or 10 should be filled up with extra villagers.