I have never made the connection between appropriating culture to appropriating EMO culture... or even thought of goth stuff like that either! Isn't emo a fashion and music subculture, rather than anything of national significance or used by minority groups? I mean, its primary icons seem to be mostly white and middle class. I feel like it's not something you need to think carefully about before doing- if real emos get upset, well, they are literally already upset! That's part of the deal, isnt it? They'll just call you "posers" and skulk away. I think its dumb when people gatekeep western fashions or subcultures of music.
The closest thing I experience to that is the lolita fashion style community, continuously trying to say to people "it's a fashion choice, not a costume! Im not dressed AS anyone, or for any event- this is just what I like to wear!" And in that case, it's not quite appropriation to wear lolita as a costume, it just makes the lolitas think you're trash and you don't understand, or you're a noob who doesnt get it.
Bookmarks