TEAM A!

[Pokemon Trainer Sarah]

Ooh nice work Noble! I found the text on the first one a little hard to read but this batch is way easier! Text is hard and it doesn't help that Shaymin's colours, pink and green, don't show up that well on each other in general. I love the new ones, especially the second one in that spoiler! Nice work with the animations! Animating stuff drives me crazy, it must have taken ages! xD

Woohoo go team!

[Noblejanobii]

Ooh nice work Noble! I found the text on the first one a little hard to read but this batch is way easier! Text is hard and it doesn't help that Shaymin's colours, pink and green, don't show up that well on each other in general. I love the new ones, especially the second one in that spoiler! Nice work with the animations! Animating stuff drives me crazy, it must have taken ages! xD

Woohoo go team!

Yeah I tried throwing some darker reds into the outer glow and drop shadows initially to make it stand out some but like I said I was going for more stylistic than legibility. Though I'm glad you like them. The initial thing took roughly four hours, mainly because I made the painful mistake of adding in the animations too early. And while that probably was a good idea to make a stylish banner that matched them, probably was not the best when it came to altering things all the time since animations are so finicky. And when you're dealing with nearly 300 frames... yikes. There is an error in the last four that I'll correct later then I have the time but I have to get ready for some stuff so it may not be today? Depends. But thanks again! I'm glad you liked it.

As I said, I'm not artistically inclined-definitely not enough to know how much time this stuff takes at all. Forgive me if I sounded rather rude about it. I'm not the kind to sugarcoat my words, and telling you where you went wrong will help you avoid mistakes in the future.

I would say the others are much better, especially the fourth. I wish I had more specific critique but I can't say I'm an art person, again. I can say that they're all a lot easier on the eyes in comparison to the first; the white glow on the middle of the larger chunks of green made it kind of hard to look at and obscured the text, so with that taken out it's much easier to see and thus makes everything blend together smoother.

You can ask Neo, if you wish for a more professional opinion, but he and I will both tell you that animations are very fickle beings. They require hours of work, and actually because I was working on quickly last night to get these done, the animation in the last four banners is messed up. I noticed last night but at that point it was nearly 2 AM and I wasn't really in the mood to fix it. I plan to address it when I get the chance today. I am dealing with a little less than 300 frames of animations, and an error in one of those frames can screw up the entire animation, which is exactly what has happened in the final four banners. One maybe two of the frames is screwed up so I'm going to have to address it.

Good. I'm glad they pleased you. I still think the first one is the best of the bunch but beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Feel free to pick whichever one looks the best and use it, but if it's one of the bottom four be sure to let me know so I can tag you when the updated non-glitchy version is fixed. I'll update them in the spoiler tags as they come and as soon as Shurikan gets the thread up I'll put them in there as well.

EDIT: Figured out the source of the issue. I've fixed one of the animations but need to leave for work soon. Will try to fix the others when I can.

EDIT 2: all the banners have been fixed and should no longer flash. If you see a flash, do let me know so I can fix it.