Stalkers RPG General Chat Thread (The Secret Clubhouse) [SEASON 3]

[The Nonexistent Tazz]

This was my list for beige
#1 Rancha the Breloom
#11 Fen the Linoone
#12 Yandil the Smeargle
#16 Vella the Buneary
#51 Ninian the Numel - furry???
#52 Jeb the Mawile - seems more yellow??
#53 Pyra the Leafeon

I dunno what Numel is made out of and Mawile might be out, but I think Leafeon and Breloom are still beige and furry right?

I agree about the mission disclosure, it's hard to know if it'll go up just from talking to a stalker or whatever... It didn't go up from talking to Yandil last time. So I'm interested to see if it goes up this time as we spoke to Jeddi.

Breloom are unlikely to be furry; they're mushrooms. In any case; we have the magic courtesy of the Bulbapedia Pokedex color search, which states Mawile is officially gray (though the parts you are concerned about probably are yellow, and a yellow too bright to be confused for beige), Numel is Yellow (and still too bright for beige) while Breloom and Leafeon are officially green. The fur of a Smeargle or Linoone is officially white, while the fur of a Buneary is officially brown, which makes this a conundrum and a half...

I don't know, but I think Neo thought far enough ahead to predict that conversations over what would and would not be constituted as beige would have a valid solution we could actually check for accuracy. I'm not so sure on this one, though, as beige isn't a color in the PokeDex... But I'm positive that Leafeon and especially Breloom do not have fur at all.

I will admit, it's annoying to deal with a color that has at once been described as almost any given tint of color that's really, really pale, and only kinda focuses on 'sandy brown.' I can see the logic behind almost all of those, to be honest.

[Pokemon Trainer Sarah]

Breloom are unlikely to be furry; they're mushrooms. In any case; we have the magic courtesy of the Bulbapedia Pokedex color search, which states Mawile is officially gray (though the parts you are concerned about probably are yellow, and a yellow too bright to be confused for beige), Numel is Yellow (and still too bright for beige) while Breloom and Leafeon are officially green. The fur of a Smeargle or Linoone is officially white, while the fur of a Buneary is officially brown, which makes this a conundrum and a half...

I don't know, but I think Neo thought far enough ahead to predict that conversations over what would and would not be constituted as beige would have a valid solution we could actually check for accuracy. I'm not so sure on this one, though, as beige isn't a color in the PokeDex... But I'm positive that Leafeon and especially Breloom do not have fur at all.

I will admit, it's annoying to deal with a color that has at once been described as almost any given tint of color that's really, really pale, and only kinda focuses on 'sandy brown.' I can see the logic behind almost all of those, to be honest.

Yeah I don't really know... Unless Neo confirms he only went by official Pokedex colours (I think this is very unlikely actually... I'm sure it was based more on common sense than the Pokedex) then I wouldn't be ruling out Leafeon or Breloom. And I think I said this last time we had samples but we don't really know that Breloom isn't furry... I mean sure it has a mushroom on its head but it's also kind of a kangaroo xD And what, Leafeon isn't furry?!?! The Eeveelutions are foxes or something? I'm pretty sure they all have fur haha.

I just feel like we should err on the side of caution and include any Pokemon that is possible even if unlikely, otherwise we risk ruling stuff out prematurely. Doesn't mean we can't focus on those who are more likely though!

Edit:

Decided to look at previous Stalkers to see what the samples were like:

- The first vial has a few strands of purple fur. - Aromatisse
- The second vial has a blue scale. - Vaporeon
- The third vial has a few brown hairs. -Furret
- The fourth vial has an orange scale. - Dragonite
- The fifth vial has a trace of a green leaf. - Oddish
- The sixth vial has a few white hairs. - Pachirisu

Oddish's official colour is blue, Aromatisse's is pink, Dragonite's is brown... so I don't think the official Pokedex colours matter.