I am loving this idea! Sadly I don't have much of an input. I do like what I'm hearing so far, though. Maybe an overhaul of the token / achievement system IS needed. It is a bit erratic.

I was thinking that if we could find some way, we could have people be able to "buy" as many postbit Pokemon as they wish, but only able to display x amount of them. If we were somehow able to, we could have it so that the user can choose which of the Pokemon they've acquired to be displayed in their postbit.

I like the group ideas for tokens, and also how completing entire achievement groups qualify for a special userbar under the member's name. However, these userbars would either have to be really skinny, or there would have to be fewer groups.

As for quantifiable tokens, I honestly feel that those are the most fair, as they are based on fact and quantity rather than opinion and quality. I'm curious to what you were thinking of for tokens that are based on quality over quantity, though!

Looks like I had more of an input than I initially thought I would xD